Tips for cream pies and pudding
Wednesday, September 1st, 2010
Last week I had the chance to help a friend with a reception. For the event I was making several cream pies and while working on them thought of a few things as it relates to cream pies and/or puddings.
I’m not sure how many people have made a cream pie filling (custard) from scratch but it truly is simple and practically foolproof. It is not as easy as the box of instant filling but it beats the flavor tenfold.

There is also the box of cook and serve pudding which is quite simple but once again not as good as the real thing. The differences are notable.

The scratch ingredients for the filling are sugar, cornstarch (the thickener) and eggs and milk. That’s basically it.

If you were making a chocolate cream pie then you would include cocoa or chocolate in some form.
There are many recipes to choose from and you can go on line and see all that are available. But when I make a nine inch pie I ususally use a base of:
2/3 cup sugar
1/4 cup cornstarch
3 large egg yolks
2 1/2 cups whole milk
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 - 2 tablespoons butter
1/2 - 1 teaspoon flavoring
All the ingredients (minus the butter and flavoring) are placed in a saucepan and stirred with a whisk .

A whisk is essential to getting the sauce creamy and smooth. The custard will need to be stirred semi-frequently initially and then as the mixture comes to a boil it has to be stirred more vigorously and constantly. It needs to cook for a minute or two or until the starchy taste dissipates. You then remove from the heat and stir in the flavoring and butter.

The filling is poured into a prebaked, cooled crust - no need to cool the filling unless it is going over bananas. Notice that the crust has been docked (poked with the tines of a fork) before baking which helps minimize shrinkage.

Once the filling is in the pie plate immediately cover it with plastic film. 
Smooth the top with your fingers and then take to the fridge to cool.

The plastic film prevents the top of the filling from forming a “skin” and keeps it moist and creamy. (This is the chocolate filling after the plastic has been removed and is ready for whipped cream).
The cream filling should be completed a day ahead or at least early in the day so it has plenty of time to set and chill.

If you do have to rush things you can help your filling cool by placing it in an ice water bath and stirring it frequently to help cool it more quickly.
A few hours before serving whip your cream (usually one cup per nine inch pie) and sweeten it with one or two tablespoons of powdered sugar and flavoring, if you are using some.
The great thing about this custard base is that it can be adapted to several flavors.
For coconut cream: add 3/4 cup flaked coconut to the filling after it is cooked and if you want to add coconut extract to the filling you can do that as well. Top it with cream and then garnish with toasted coconut.
For chocolate cream: include a heaping 1/3 cup of cocoa with the sugar and vanilla OR you can use 2/3 cup of real semisweet chocolate chips (the equivalent of 3 ounces) OR you can substitute some of the chips for an unsweetened square of chocolate for a richer, deeper chocolate flavor. If you are using the “solid chocolates” then melt them gently and VERY CAREFULLY in the micorwave first and includ them to the custard filling as it begins to cook. You can also use brown sugar instead of white for a fudgier taste. When making the cream for this pie you can use almond flavoring for a special touch and then garnish this with the chocolate curls.
For banana cream: see an earlier post for specifics about this pie.
For pudding instead of pie filling: use only 3 tablespoons of cornstarch. That modification makes it a little less stiff.
The cream pies are just fun to play around with. You will have leftover whites which you can scramble with whole eggs for breakfast, or make an angel food cake or Pavlova which is a meringue dessert we’ll have to talk about sometime but you can check out on line. There are always uses for the whites and they can be frozen and accumulated for such uses.












